- This topic has 26 replies, 17 voices, and was last updated 5 years, 7 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
I am on the verge of doing my roof but I have not decided on a shingle brand. I was wondering what is a good brand of shingle or are there any brands you guys recommend staying away from. As always I appreciate the good advice.
Thanks
Mark
I am partial to Certainteed shingles but Owens Corning (sold at Lowe’s) is a very close second. GAF (sold at Home Depot) is also a good brand.
Chad
A Working Pro since 1993
Member since 12/07/2013If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Timberline makes a good shingle. I think if you stay with most any name brand your ok. I personally think the architectural shingles are easier to put on and less waste. I have used Tamco shingles and they were ok.
Steel roofs are really nice too if you like that look. Don’t forget the ice guard as well.If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Never realized how many variables were involved with the types of material on a metal roof. Tree split and hit our house last year. We had slate and it took a pretty rough beating in several areas. Had some Amish friends of ours put steel on. Two story farm house, looks great, and I don’t plan on doing anything else to that roof for quite awhile, if ever.
They are all pretty equal to me. I install Owens Corning, Tamko, Gaf,certinteed, pinnacle, Iko, others too. Each had problems here and there through the years. Nothing to bad but….
Oc Tamko and Gaf were the big 3 here.
Working Pro since 1993
Tom M
Had the roof redone with IKO shingles 10 years ago. During eaves trough cleaning this spring I discovered that the south exposure is losing granules and curling so bad in places that replacement will be necessary soon.
10 years ago metal shingles were new enough that I wasn’t confident in their longevity. A roof done with them down the block same year as my roof looks like new. My neighbor did his roof with metal shingles last month because he was tired of replacing “25” year asphalt shingles every 12 or so years. I’m feeling the same.
So my recommendation is check into them. Haven’t started research yet so if anyone can recommend brands that would be helpful.Certainteed or Owens Corning. IKO or Atlas are junk.
Andrew
A Working Pro since 1995!
Member since March 26, 2014.
I think you are going to find there are a inch of opinions about shingles…look for a long warranty, as that generally implies a higher quality product. I’m not a roofer, but GAF Timberline shingles are all I’ve used on the last few projects I’ve done and they still look great 5 years later. Do yourself a favor and make sure he roof is vented adequately. A poorly vented roof leads to premature shingle failure.
Jon P.
Timber Carpentry & Construction
https://www.facebook.com/timbercarpentry/
InstagramCertainteed or Owens Corning. IKO or Atlas are junk.
I have never used IKO but Atlas are garbage.
Do yourself a favor and make sure he roof is vented adequately. A poorly vented roof leads to premature shingle failure.
Proper venting one of the most important, and most overlooked, part of a new roof.
Chad
A Working Pro since 1993
Member since 12/07/2013If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Never realized how many variables were involved with the types of material on a metal roof. Tree split and hit our house last year. We had slate and it took a pretty rough beating in several areas. Had some Amish friends of ours put steel on. Two story farm house, looks great, and I don’t plan on doing anything else to that roof for quite awhile, if ever.
I am having that same debate right now, either go all steel or just your regular shingle. I haven’t decided yet.
If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Never realized how many variables were involved with the types of material on a metal roof. Tree split and hit our house last year. We had slate and it took a pretty rough beating in several areas. Had some Amish friends of ours put steel on. Two story farm house, looks great, and I don’t plan on doing anything else to that roof for quite awhile, if ever.
I am having that same debate right now, either go all steel or just your regular shingle. I haven’t decided yet.
I have steel on my house and it holds up very well being in a windy region .
If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Never realized how many variables were involved with the types of material on a metal roof. Tree split and hit our house last year. We had slate and it took a pretty rough beating in several areas. Had some Amish friends of ours put steel on. Two story farm house, looks great, and I don’t plan on doing anything else to that roof for quite awhile, if ever.
I was brought up in a home that was built in the 1880’s and had a slate shingle roof. My parents moved out of that home in early 2000’s and that roof never needed any repairs.
The next time I have to replace my shingles, I might just go with metal shingles, quite a few homes in my area are starting with them.I have 25 yr IKO on my home and garage and as mentioned the longevity of the shingles also depends on how well your attic vents out air. Next for my roof is a ridge vent. I think that will allow for more venting than just having the 5 little vents that are there now.
“If you don’t pass on the knowledge you have to others, it Dies with you”
— Glenn BottingThanks for all the feedback. I spent yesterday doing some more homework and I believe we are going to go with the GAF by Timberline. I few people I spoke to (and I believe it was mentioned in here) was that these days there is not really much difference in the quality of shingles.
Thanks again
I got here late. I would have been somebody who also voted for steel roof. One thing I didn’t see mentioned in any of the comments was to be sure and buy shingles made for your market area. Evidently shingles are made with different cold and heat tolerances you get one that’s not made specifically for your area you can have problems. It happened to a guy here locally who bought some shingles from a different region cheap cheap on one of the websites. It cost him more than he saved.
I just reroofed mine with Owens Corning. Looks really nice and the quality looked pretty good to me.
My neighbour just did his house with GAF shingles which are made to look like cedar shakes. In my opinion they look really good. Its also kind of nice to see shingle companies do something to dress up shingles as opposed to the tradional style shingle.
If this is your forever home, have you given thought to those steel roofs where you never have to replace them ever again?
Never realized how many variables were involved with the types of material on a metal roof. Tree split and hit our house last year. We had slate and it took a pretty rough beating in several areas. Had some Amish friends of ours put steel on. Two story farm house, looks great, and I don’t plan on doing anything else to that roof for quite awhile, if ever.
I was brought up in a home that was built in the 1880’s and had a slate shingle roof. My parents moved out of that home in early 2000’s and that roof never needed any repairs.
The next time I have to replace my shingles, I might just go with metal shingles, quite a few homes in my area are starting with them.I have 25 yr IKO on my home and garage and as mentioned the longevity of the shingles also depends on how well your attic vents out air. Next for my roof is a ridge vent. I think that will allow for more venting than just having the 5 little vents that are there now.
How hard is it to do metal shingles? I think i’ve still got a few years till my shingles go. Depending on cost and whatnot I’ll figure it out after the porch.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.